¤¸·Ó


¹Ï®Ñ

¥DÃD¹Ï®Ñ
¥N²zÁ`¸g¾P

Àu´f¬¡°Ê


¤¸·Ó¡G ªk«ß¾Ç²ß¡D¬ã¨s

·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk I ¡X ¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤µ©õ

·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk I ¡X ¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤µ©õ

¡i§@¡@ªÌ¡jºµ»w±ö
¡i®Ñ¡@¸¹¡j 5D507RA
¡i¥Xª©ªÀ¡j ¤¸·Ó¥Xª©¤½¥q
¡i¥X¡@ª©¡j 2018/11
¡iª©¡@¦¸¡j 1
¡iISBN/ISSN¡j978-986-255-124-0
¡i©w¡@»ù¡j480 ¤¸
¡i¯S¡@»ù¡j432 ¤¸
¸ÕŪ¡G 1
 
 
 ¥»®Ñ²¤¶

¡@¡@¥»®Ñ«Y´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|ºµ»w±öªk©x²Ö¿n¦h¦~¤§¿ì®×¤Î¬ã¨s¤ß±o¡A±N¨ä©ó´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¦¨¥ß«e«á©Ò¼¶¼g¤§¤Q¼Æ½g¤¤­^¤å³¹¶°µ²¦¨¥U¡A°£¤F¨£ÃÒ´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¦¨¥ß«e«á¡A¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§ÅÜ­²¥~¡A¤]¥H¨ä­Ó¤H©ó´¼¼z°]²£»â°ì¤§¾Ç²ß¹Lµ{¡A¬M®g¥Xªñ¤G¤Q¦h¦~¨Ó¡A¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£ªk¾Ç±Ð¨|±q¹L¥h¤§¯î¿¾¨´¤µ½´«kµo®i¤§¥ú´º¡C¦¹¥~¡AÂǥѨî«×§ï­²¤§±´°Q¤Î´¼°]§P¨M¤§µûªR¡A´£¥X¹ï¥xÆW´¼°]¹êÅéªk¤Îµ{§Çªk¤§«Ø¨¥¡A¬Û«HŪªÌ¥²¯à±q¦¹®Ñ¤§¤Þ¤¶¡A¦h¤è­±¤F¸Ñ¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤µ©õ¡C±©¦³¤F¸Ñ¥ßªkªu­²¤§Âà§é¡A¨î«×µo®i¤§¾ú¥v¡Aª¾¬GŲ¤µ¡A¤~¯à¥H§ó²Ï¹ê¤§ºA«×´£¤É¥xÆW¤§´¼¼z°]²£¥qªk¤å¤Æ¡C

 
 ¹Ï®Ñ¥Ø¿ý

±ÀÂ˧ǡþ°ª¨q¯u
Recommendation¡þRobert P. Merges
¦A¨ê§Ç
¦Û§Ç¡X¡X¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤µ©õ
Preface
Acknowledgements

·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk¡X¡X±q±M§Q¶D³^¨î«×½Í°_
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ1
¡@¶L¡B§Ú°êªº±M§Q¶D³^¨î«×¡þ7
¡@°Ñ¡Bªk°|¤G¤¸¨î»P¶D³^µ{§Ç¤§°±¤î¡þ15
¡@¸v¡B¦æ¬F³B¤À¹ï¥Á¨Æªk°|ªº®Ä¤O¡þ17
¡@¥î¡B¥Á¨Æ¶D³^§P¨M»P¦æ¬F¶D³^§P¨M¶¡¤§®Ä¤O¡þ20
¡@³°¡Bµ²¡@½×¡þ22

±M§Q«IÅv¥Á¨Æ§P¨M²ªR
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ25
¡@¶L¡B±M§Q«IÅv¥Á¨Æ§P¨M¤§¯S¦â¡þ30
¡@°Ñ¡B±M§Q«IÅv¥Á¨Æ§P¨M¤§«I®`»{©w¡þ33
¡@¸v¡B±M§Q«IÅv¥Á¨Æ§P¨M¤§±ÏÀ٤覡¡þ39
¡@¥î¡Bµ²»y¡X¡X±M§Q¶D³^¨î«×ªº§ï¶i¡þ44

³]¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§µû¦ô¬ã¨s
¡@³ü¡B¦¨¥ßªk°|¤§¥Øªº¤Î­n¥ó¡þ49
¡@¶L¡B¦¨¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§¥²­n©Ê¡þ53
¡@°Ñ¡B¥xÆW¦¨¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§¯ó®×¤è¦V¡þ64
¡@¸v¡B­q©w´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|ªk¡þ74
¡@¥î¡Bµ²¡@½×¡þ77

±q¥~¦b¦]¯À»P¤º¦b»Ý¨D½Í¥xÆW¦¨¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§«´¾÷»P¥²­n
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ79
¡@¶L¡B¥xÆW«Ø¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§½t°_¡þ81
¡@°Ñ¡B¥xÆW¦¨¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§¤º¦b»Ý¨D»P¥~¦b¦]¯À¡þ93
¡@¸v¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ101

·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk¡X¡X±q´¼¼z°]²£®×¥ó¼f²zªk¯ó®×²Ä16±ø½Í°_
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ103
¡@¶L¡B¤½¨pªk¤G¤¸½×¹ï´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¤§ÑèÕÀ¡þ108
¡@°Ñ¡B´¼¼z°]²£§½±Â¤©±M§Q¡B°Ó¼ÐÅv¤§©Ê½è»P®Ä¤O¡þ115
¡@¸v¡B¦æ¬F¼f¬d¶D³^»P¥Á¨Æ«IÅv¶D³^¤§¦X¤@¡þ129
¡@¥î¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ140

±q³Ì°ªªk°|§P¨M½Í±M§Q«IÅv¤§¥DÆ[­n¥ó
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ141
¡@¶L¡B³Ì°ªªk°|¹ï±M§Q«IÅv¥DÆ[­n¥ó¤§¨£¸Ñ¡þ143
¡@°Ñ¡B±M§Q«IÅv±Æ°£«I®`¤§¥DÆ[­n¥ó¡þ146
¡@¸v¡B±M§Q«IÅv·l®`½ßÀv¤§¥DÆ[­n¥ó¡þ149
¡@¥î¡Bµ²½×¡X¡X¥DÆ[­n¥óÁ|ÃÒ³d¥ôªº¤À°t¡þ157
¡@³°¡B«á¡@°O¡þ160

­n¦h¯µ±K¤~¯µ±K¡X¡X½Í¯µ±K«O«ù©R¥O
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ161
¡@¶L¡B²{¦æªk¦b¶D³^¤¤Ãö©óÀç·~¯µ±Kªº«OÅ@¡þ163
¡@°Ñ¡BÀç·~¯µ±K¤§«OÅ@»P¶D³^¼f²z¥D¸q¤§½Ä¬ð¡þ165
¡@¸v¡B´¼¼z°]²£®×¥ó¼f²zªk¹ï¶D³^¤¤Àç·~¯µ±Kªº«OÅ@¡þ168
¡@¥î¡B¯µ±K«O«ù©R¥Oªº®Öµo­n¥ó¡þ169
¡@³°¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ176

ªk®x¤W¤§±M§Q§Þ³Nª§Ä³
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ179
¡@¶L¡B§Þ³Nª§Ä³©ó±M§Qªk¤W¤§¾A¥Î¡þ180
¡@°Ñ¡B¬ü°ê±M§Q¶D³^¹ï©ó§Þ³Nª§Ä³¤§¸Ñ¨M¾÷¨î¡þ185
¡@¸v¡B¥xÆW§Þ³N¼f¬d©x¨î«×¤§²z½×»P¹ê°È¡þ190
¡@¥î¡Bµ²¡@»y¡þ197

­¹¤§µL¨ý¡A±ó¤§¥i±¤¡X¡X½Í±M§Q¼Ð¥Ü
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ199
¡@¶L¡B±q¥ßªkªu­²¬Ý±M§Q¼Ð¥Ü¡þ201
¡@°Ñ¡B±q¥xÆW¥qªk¹ê°È¨£±M§Q¼Ð¥Ü¡þ204
¡@¸v¡B±q¬ü°ê¥qªk¹ê°È¨£±M§Q¼Ð¥Ü¡þ210
¡@¥î¡Bµ²»y¡X¡X±q¬Fµ¦Æ[ÂI¤ÀªR±M§Q¼Ð¥Ü¡þ221

¥xÆW±M§Q®v©ó´¼Åv¶D³^¤§¨¤¦â»P©w¦ì
¡@³ü¡B«e¡@¨¥¡þ225
¡@¶L¡B±M§Q®vªkªº³q¹L¡þ228
¡@°Ñ¡B±M§Q§Þ³Nª§Ä³¦b±M§Qªk¤W¾A¥Î¤§§xÃø¡þ230
¡@¸v¡B±M§Q®v©ó´¼Åv¶D³^¤§¥\¯à¡þ232
¡@¥î¡B´Á³\»P«Øij¡þ233

The International Trend of Judicial Role in Intellectual Property Protection¡X¡XFrom U.S. to Asia
¡@A. The Predominant Developments of the Asian Legal System As Influenced by Its U.S. Counterpart¡þ235
¡@B. The Birth of Intellectual Property Court in the Asian Legal System - Thailand, Korea and Japan¡þ238
¡@C. The Establishment of the Intellectual Property Court in Taiwan and the Discussion of that in China¡þ244
¡@D. Other Asian Legal Systems¡¦ Intellectual Property Protection¡þ252
¡@E. Are Specialized Courts Panaceas to Resolve Intellectual Property Litigation¡þ253

The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit¡X¡XThe Good and the Bad
¡@A. The Mandate of the Federal Circuit¡þ259
¡@B. The Creation of the Federal Circuit¡þ277
¡@C. The Specialization of the Federal Circuit¡þ282
¡@D. The Success and Criticism of the Federal Circuit¡þ295
¡@E. The Reform Proposal for the Federal Circuit¡þ305

An Overview of Intellectual Property Court in Taiwan
¡@A. A Brief Introduction of Intellectual Property Litigation in Taiwan¡þ311
¡@B. The Establishment of Taiwan¡¦s Intellectual Property Court¡þ318
¡@C. The Characteristics of Taiwan¡¦s Intellectual Property Court¡þ326
¡@D. The Outlook of Intellectual Property Court in Taiwan¡þ332

 §@ªÌ²¤¶

ºµ»w±ö

²{¡@¾
¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|ªk©x
¾Ç¡@¾ú
¬ü°ê¬f§JµÜ¥[¦{¤j¾Çªk¾ÇºÓ¤h¡B³Õ¤h
¥xÆW¤j¾Çªk¾Ç¾Ç¤h¡BºÓ¤h
¸g¡@¾ú
¥xÆW¥x¥_¦aªk¤èªk°|ªk©x
¥qªk°|¦æ¬F¶D³^¤ÎÃg§ÙÆU½Õ¿ì¨Æ¡]¬ã¨s¡^ªk©x
¥qªk°|¦æ¬F¶D³^¨î«×¬ã¨s­×¥¿©e­û·|¬ã¨s­û
ªk©x¾Ç°|¤Î¥qªk©x¾Ç°|´¼¼z°]²£®×¨Ò½Òµ{Á¿®y
¬ü°êÁp¨¹¨µ°j¤W¶Dªk°|³X°Ýªk©x
´¼¼z°]²£Åvªk­Ý¥ô±Ð±Â
ªk¥O¤ë¥Z½s¼f©e­û

 
 §Ç¡@¤å

±ÀÂ˧Ç

¡@¡@ºµ»w±öªk©x¬O¬ü°ê¬f§JµÜ¥[¦{¤j¾Çªk¾Ç°|ªk¾Ç³Õ¤h¡A±q¨Æ¥qªk¼f§P¤u§@ªø¹F¤Q¤C¦~¡A¨ä¶¡´¿½Õ¥qªk°|¿ì¨Æ¤G¦~¡A¦³¥qªk¦æ¬F¤§¸gÅç¡A²{¥ô´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|ªk©x¡A±M¨Æ¼f²z´¼¼z°]²£¥Á¨Æ¡B¦D¨Æ¤Î¦æ¬F¶D³^¨Æ¥ó¡C
¡@¡@ºµªk©xªø´ÁÃöÃh¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×ªº¹B§@©M¥\¯à¡A¦b¼f§P¤u§@Ác¦£¤§¤¤¡AµS­P¤O©ó¶Ê¤Æ¶D³^¨î«×¤§­²·s¡A¥H¨ä»y¤å¯à¤O¤Î¼ô¸Z¬ã¨s¤èªk¤§±Mªø¡A¨t²Î¤Æ¤Þ¤¶¦U°ê´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¡A¤©¥H¤ñ¸û¤ÀªR¡A´£¨Ñ«Ø¨¥¡A§@¬°¥qªk¦æ¬F¾÷Ãö³W¹º¨î«×¤§­«­n°Ñ¾Ú¡A¨Ã´N¬ã¨s¡B¼f§P¡B°Ñ»P·|ij¤§¬ÛÃö½×µÛ¶°µ²¦¨®Ñ¡C¥»®Ñ¤åµ§¬yºZ¡Aµø³¥§»Æ[¡A±Ô¨Æ©ú½T§ã­n¡A¥Ñ¹ê°È°ÝÃD¤Á¤J¡A­z¤Þ­Ó¤H¿Ë¦Û°Ñ»P¤§¸gÅç¡A¦õÃҩҲߨî«×¤Î²z½×¬ã¨s¤§¤ß±o¡A¦b»â°ì¤W²[»\¤FªF¦è¤è¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤ÀªR¡Aµ{§Ç¤W¿Ä§M¤F¥Á¨Æ¡B¦D¨Æ¡B¦æ¬F¶D³^¤Î´¼¼z°]²£®×¥ó¼f²zªk¯S§O³W©w¤§À³¥Î¡A¹êÅéªk¤W½×­z±M§Qªk¡B°Ó¼Ðªk¡BµÛ§@Åvªk¶D³^¤W±`¨£ª§Ä³°ÝÃD¤§¨£¸Ñ¡A¨ÃÆ[¹î¨ì¥xÆW±M§Q®v¦¹¤@·s¿³±M·~¡A¦b´¼¼z°]²£Åv¶D³^¤§°Ñ»P¤Î¨ä«P¶i¥\¯à¡A¥i¿×¬O¤F¸Ñ´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^ªº¤Jªù®ÑÄy¡A¾\¤§¹ï´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¤§ºt¶i¤Î¥Ø«e·s¨î¤§¹B§@»P±`¨£°ÝÃD¤§³B²z¡A¯à¦³©ú´·¤§»{ÃÑ¡A¦b²z½×¤Î¹ê°È¬Ò¦³°Ñ¦Ò»ù­È¡C

´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|  °|ªø     
°ª¨q¯u


Recommendation

   I am most pleased to have the honor of writing a Preface to this book by Judge Sungmei Hsiung. Sungmei was a most outstanding student at U.C. Berkeley Law School where I had the privilege to supervise the research and writing of her dissertation for our J.S.D. (Doctor of Juridical Science) degree. And now I am pleased to be able to recommend to all readers the product of Sungmei¡¦s diligent research and hard work.

   The research in this book represents some very thoughtful observations and insights on extremely important topics in the field of intellectual property, particularly patent law. A number of chapters in this book focus on the highly significant issue of the role and function of specialized IP courts. Sungmei has researched the history and structure of the Federal Circuit in the U.S., as well as the specialized IP courts of the major Asian countries ¡V Taiwan, Korea, China, and Japan. She has examined not only the legislative details regarding each court but also the scholarly literature about their origins, functioning, and the pressing problems they face today. The attention to both the practical operation of these courts and the scholarly opinion regarding their strengths and weaknesses is a unique contribution of this book. I have personally learned much of value from Sungmei on these issues, for example, the unique and innovative use of technical examination officers (TEOs) in Taiwan¡¦s new IP Court. I believe it is safe to say that on the topic of the comparative law of specialized IP courts, particularly those in Asia, Sungmei is perhaps the preeminent world expert at this time.

   I hope you enjoy and learn from Sungmei¡¦s research as much as I have. It is my honor to recommend it to you, and to say that the Taiwan courts and IP system as a whole are fortunate to have this diligent scholar and shining star to learn from.


Professor Robert P. Merges
U.C. Berkeley School of Law
Robert P. Merges


¦A¨ê§Ç

¡@¡@»à¥ú¯ö­\¡A¶Z·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk²Ä¤@¥»½×¤å¶°µo¦æ¨´¤µ¤w¹O7¦~¡A®Ñ¦­¤w°âÁj¡A²{¬°°t¦X·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk²Ä¤G¥»½×¤å¶°¡Ð¶³ºÝ¤Wªº´¼¼z°]²£Åv¤§¥Xª©¦Ó¦A¨ê¡C¥»½×¤å¶°¤ºªº¤å³¹¡A¦Û¼g§@¨´¤µ¤w¦³¬Û·í®É¤é¡A¦ý¦]¤º®e¦h¯A¤Î¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤µ©õ¤ñ¹ï¡A©ó¦¹¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¦¨¥ß¤Q©P¦~¤§»Ú¡AŪ¨Ó®æ¥~¦³·P¡C´Á«Ý«B·sª¾¡AÄ~Äòµ¹¤©§åµû«ü±Ð¡I

 
ºµ»w±ö
¤G¡³¤@¤K¦~¤Q¤ë


¦Û¡@§Ç

¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§¤µ©õ

¡@¡@¥xÆW¹ï´¼¼z°]²£ªk«ß¤§±À¼s»P¹ê½î¡AÀHµÛ´¼¼z°]²£ªk«ß¬ã¨s©Ò¡B¬ì§Þªk«ß¬ã¨s©Ò¤§½´«kµo®i¡A¤w¦³¬Û·í¤§³W¼Ò»P¶i¨B¡C¯S§O¬O¦b¹êÅéªk³¡¤À¡A¬°¥[¤J°ê»Ú²Õ´©Ò¬°¤§¾ú¦¸­×§ï¡A¤wÅý¥xÆW¤§´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î°ê»Ú¤Æ¡A¨Ã»P¥@¬É±µ­y¡A¦ý³¯Âªº´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¡A«o¤´¥O´¼¼z°]²£Åv§Q¤H±æ¦Ó«o¨B¡A¥BÅý«D¥¿·íÅv§Q¤HÆpÀç±o§Q¡C¤G¡³¡³¤T¡B¤G¡³¡³¥|¦~¶¡¡A¹ê°È¬ÉÀ±º©µÛ¤@¤ù¡u¥xÆW±M§QµL¥Î½×¡vªº©IÁn¡A¾_¾Ù¤F¬ÛÃö²£·~¡B¾Ç³N¤Î¥qªk¹ê°È¬É¤H¤h¡A¨ä¤¤ªk«ß°õ¦æªºµL®Ä²v¡A§Y«Y´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤£¹üªº³Ì¥D­n­ì¦]¤§£¸¡C¦Óªk«ß°õ¦æªºµL®Ä²v¡A¤S«Y°ò©ó¹ï´¼¼z°]²£Åv¥»½è¤§¤£¤F¸Ñ¡C´¼¼z°]²£¬J²o¯A¬ì§Þ¡BºÞ²z¤Îªk«ß¤§¾ã¦X¡A¤S¾î¸ó¤½ªk¤Î¨pªk¤§¥æ¿ù»â°ì¡A¦]¦¹¶Ç²Î¶D³^¨î«×ªº³]­p¡A¤wµLªk¦]À³´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤§¤é·s¤ë²§¡C
¡@¡@¨ä¹ê¬ÛÃö´¼¼z°]²£¤§ªk«ß¨î«×¡A¦p±M§Q¡B°Ó¼Ð¡BµÛ§@¤ÎÀç·~¯µ±Kµ¥¡A·¹¨ä¾ú¥v¯ßµ¸¡A§¡«Y¶W¹L¼Æ¦Ê¦~¥H¤W¤§¥j¦Ñªk¨î¡A¦ý¬O¦b§Ú±µ¨ü°ò¦ªk¾Ç±Ð¨|ªº¤@¤E¤K¡³¦~¥N¥½´Á¡A«o¬O¤@­Ó·s¿³ªk»â°ìªºµÞªÞ®É´Á¡A§Ú¥u¿ï­×¤F¤@ªù¤G¾Ç¤Àªº¤u·~°]²£Åvªk¡C¤@¤E¤E¥|¦~¥½¡A§Úªì¥ô¥xÆW¥x¥_¦a¤èªk°|ªk©x¡A¦]½t»Ú·|¦Ó©½¬°¦D¨Æ®x´¼¼z°]²£±MªÑªk©x¡A·í®É«Y±Ä±MªÑ½ü¿ì¦ý¤]­Ý¿ì¨ä¥L®×¥ó¡A¦]¦¹¹j¦~´N¥æ¥X¤F±MªÑÄ_®y¡C¤@¤E¤E¤C¦~¡A§Ú¦b¿ì²z¤Ö¦~¨Æ¥ó®É¡A³\¦h¤Ö¦~¦]¨ü°U³c½æ¤j¸É©«¥úºÐ¦Ó¹Hªk¡A¦]¦¹´¿¨üÁܾá¥ô¦h³õ¥Ñ·í®ÉµÛ§@Åvªk¤§¥DºÞ¾÷Ãö¤º¬F³¡µÛ§@Åv©e­û·|¥D¿ìªº®Õ¶éµÛ§@Åv¨µ°jÁ¿®y¡A¥H¤Î¥x¥_«ß®v¤½·|¬°°ê¤¤¦Ñ®vÁ|¿ìªº´¼¼z°]²£Åvªk¬ã²ßÀç¡C¨ä«á§Ú§ï¿ì²z¥Á¨Æ¨Æ¥ó®É¡A´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤w³vº¥¶i¤J¶}ªá®É´Á¡C¤dÁH¦~«e«á¡A§Ú°Ñ¥[¤F³\¦h¥Ñ¸gÀÙ³¡´¼¼z°]²£§½Á|¿ìªº¬ã²ß¬¡°Ê¥H¤Î¦U¬ÛÃöªk«ß¬ã¨s©ÒÁ|¿ìªº¾Ç³N¬ã°Q·|¤Î¤j«¬°ê»Ú´¼¼z°]²£ªk«ß¬ã°Q·|¡AµÛ¹ê¶}¤F§Úªº²´¬É¡A¤Þ°_§Ú§ó²`¤J¬ã¨s´¼¼z°]²£»â°ìªº¿³½ì¡C¦P®É¶¡§Ú¶}©lµÛ¤â¼¶¼g¥qªk°|¤§¦~«×¬ã¨s³ø§i¡X¡X¡uªk©x¿ì²z±M§Q«IÅv¥Á¨Æ¶D³^¤â¥U¡v¡A¦Ü¤G¡³¡³¤G¦~©³§¹½Z¡A¦Ó¤µÆ[¤§¡A©Î¦³¤£§¹³Æ¡B²¨º|¬Æ¦Ü¿ù»~¤§³B¡A¦ý«o¬°§Ú¹ï´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤§¬ã¨s³þ¤U°ò¦¡C
¡@¡@§Ú­ì¨Ó¦bªk«ß¾Ç¬ã¨s©Ò«Y¤½ªk²Õªº¾Ç¥Í¡AºÓ¤h½×¤å¬°¤¤°ê¤j³°¸gÀÙ¥òµô¨î«×¤§¬ã¨s¡A·í®É¤j³°ªº¸gÀÙ¥òµô¡A¹ê«Y±Ä¦æ¬F¶D³^¨î«×¡C¤£¹L¿ï¾Ü³o­ÓÃD¥Ø¡A¤@¤è­±¦]¬°¦b·í®É¤¤°êªº¾Ç³N¸ê®Æ¨Ã¤£®e©ö¨ú±o¡A§Ú¦]¬°¾á¥ô°ê¬ì·|©e°U­pµeªº¬ã¨s§U²z¡A¦]¦Ó±o¥H±µÄ²·í®É³Ì·sªº¸ê®Æ¡A¤@¤è­±¤]¦]¬°¤w¸g¦Ò¤W¥qªk©x¯S¦Ò¡A¤£·Q¤@¦A©µ°V¡A©Ò¥H¡AÁöµM³o¥»½×¤å´¿Àò±o¦æ¬F°|¤j³°©e­û·|¹{µoªº¾Ç³N½×¤å¼ú¾Çª÷¡A¦ý¦b§Ú¤º¤ß²`³B¡A°¸º¸ÁÙ¬Oı±o¦³ÂI¶d­t¤F³Ì¾A¦X¬ã¨sªº«C¬K®É¥ú¡C¤G¡³¡³¤G¦~¤K¤ë¡A¦]¬°´¿¬O¤½ªk²Õ¬ã¨s¥Í¤§¬G¡A½Õ¦Ü¥qªk°|¦æ¬F¶D³^¤ÎÃg§ÙÆU¿ì¨Æ¡C¨ä¹ê¦Û±qÂ÷¶}¬ã¨s©Ò«á¡A¦]ªø´Á¿ì²z¤@¯ë¥Á¡B¦D¨Æ¼f§P¡A¤½ªk­ì«h¤Î²z½×´N¹³¦b¸£®ü¤¤¨IºÎ¡A¦b¥qªk°|½Õ¿ì¨Æ´Á¶¡ºCºC³Q³ê°_µd¿ô¡CÁÙ°O±o·í®É§Ú³ÌÅå³Yªº´N¬O·íªì¦b°á¬ã¨s©Ò´Á¶¡¡A¤½ªk¦Ñ®v­Ì¿n·¥©IÆ~ªº½Ò¤©¸q°È¶D³^¡A¤w¸g¦¨¬°©ú¤å³W½d¡A¥BÀHµÛ°ªµ¥¦æ¬Fªk°|ªº¦¨¥ß¡A¤½ªk¤§¬ã¨s¦b¾Ç³N¤Î¹ê°È¤§§V¤O¤U¡A¤]¤w½´«kµo®i¡BªYªY¦Vºa¡C¦Ó¬ÛÃö´¼¼z°]²£ªk«ß¡A¤£¶È¥»¨­§Y«Y¦æ¬Fªk¤§³W©w¡A¤]±`±`¨ü¨ì¨ä¥L¦æ¬Fªk³W½d¤§¼vÅT¡A¦A°t¦XµÛ¥xÆWªk°|¤G¤¸¨î¤§µo®i¡A¦æ¬F¶D³^¤G¯Å¤G¼f¨î¤§¶}®i¡A¨Ï´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¦¨¬°¤@­Ó¬Û·í¿ùºî½ÆÂøªºªk¨î¡A©Û­P°ê¤º¥~¤§§åµû¡C¤G¡³¡³¤T¦~¤»¤ë¡A§Úµoªí¤F²Ä¤@½g¦³Ãö´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤§½×¤å¡X¡X¡u·í¤½ªk¹J¤W¨pªk¡X¡X±q±M§Q¶D³^¨î«×½Í°_¡v¡AÀË°Q¥xÆW±M§Q¶D³^¨î«×¤§½ÆÂø»PµL®Ä²v¡A¨Ã´£¥X¤@¨Ç§ï­²ªº«Øij¡C
¡@¡@¤G¡³¡³¥|¦~¤G¤ë¡A¥qªk°|©Ó¨ü¨Ó¦Û°ê¤º¥~¤§À£¤O¤Î¦Û¨­¤§Ä±¿ô¡A¶}©l¶i¦æ´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§Äw¹º¡A·í®É§ÚÁÙ¦b¥qªk°|¦æ¬F¶D³^¤ÎÃg§ÙÆUªA°È¡A¦P¦~¤K¤ë¥X°ê¶i­×«e¤i¡A©^ÆU¸Ì«ü¥Ü¼g¤F¤@¥»¬ã¨s³ø§i¡X¡X¡u³]¥ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤§µû¦ô¬ã¨s¡X¡X­Ý½×¼w°ê¡BÁú°ê¤Î¤é¥»¤§±M§Q¶D³^¨î«×¡v¡A¸Ó³ø§i©ó¤K¤ë¤»¤é¥Xª©¡A¤K¤ë¤Q¤@¤é§Ú§Y¨Ì­ì­q­pµe»P¥þ®a»ô­u¬ü°ê¬f§JµÜ¥[¦{¤j¾Çªk¾Ç°|¡]University of California, Berkeley School of Law¡^¶i­×¡A¤K¤ë¤Q¤C¤é¶}¾Ç¡C¥X°ê«e¤§¥^¦£»P²V¶Ã¡A¨´¤µ¤´Ä±±oÃø¥H·Q¹³¡C¥X°ê¯d¾Ç¡A¤@ª½¬O§Ú¤j¾Ç®É´Áªº¹Ú·Q¡A¦ýÀHµÛ¦Ò¤W¥qªk©x¯S¦Ò¡B«ß®v°ª¦Ò¡B¨ü°V¡B¤Àµo¦Ó´Xªñ©ñ±ó¡A¸g¹L¦h¦~ªº§V¤O¡A²×©ó¦b¤G¡³¡³¤T¦~©³³q¹L¥qªk°|ªº±a¾±aÁ~¶i­×­pµe¡A¥B¸g¹L¤@¯ë¥Ó½Ðµ{§Ç¡A¿ï¾Ü©ó¤G¡³¡³¥|¦~¤K¤ë¤¤­u¬ü°ê·s»D¤Î¥@¬É³ø¾É¡]U.S. News & World Report¡^³sÄò¤Q¼Æ¦~§¡©ó´¼¼z°]²£ªk»â°ìµû»ù²Ä¤@ªº¬f§JµÜªk¾Ç°|´NŪ¡C¤u§@¤Q¦~«á­«¬°¾Ç¥Í¡A½T¹ê¬O¤@¥ó¥O¤H¿³¾Äªº¨Æ¡C¬f§JµÜªº´ïÂŶ§¥ú¡B¦Û¥Ñ­·®ð¡A­«·s³ê°_§Úªº¾Ç³NÆF»î¡A§Ú«D±`»{¯u¦a¾Ç²ß¡A§V¤O¦a°Ñ»Pªk¾Ç°|ªº¦U¶µ¬¡°Ê¡AºÉ§Ú©Ò¯à¦a»P¦P¾Ç¤Î¦Ñ®v­Ì¤¬°Ê¡A·Q­nÀ±¸É·í¦~¨S¯à¦n¦n¾Ç²ßªº¬ã¨s©Ò®É¥ú¡A¦]¦¹¤£¦ý©óºÓ¤h¯Z¤@¦~¤§½Òµ{¤º¡A¨ú±o¬f§JµÜªk¾Ç°|¬ì§Þªk«ß¤¤¤ß¹{µoªºµ²·~ÃҮѡA¤]¦b«ü¾É¦Ñ®vRobert P. Mergesªº­«­«¦Ò®Ö¤U¡AÀò¨ä±ÀÂ˦Ӷi¤J³Õ¤h¯Z½Òµ{¡A¨Ã©ó¤G¡³¡³¤K¦~¤­¤ë²¦·~¡C¬f§JµÜªk¾Ç°|¬O§Ú¤H¥Í¤¤¤@­Ó©¯¹Bªº¿ï¾Ü¡A¤£¥u¬O¦]¬°¨ä´¼¼z°]²£ªk«ß½Òµ{¤Î¬ÛÃö¬¡°Ê¤§Â×´I¡A¦Ó¥B§Ú¦b¾Ç®Õ³B³B³£¯à¬Ý¨ìºµ¡]ÀJ¹³¡^ªºÂܸñ¡A«á¨Ó¤~ª¾¹D­ì¨ÓBerkeley¥Nªíªº·N«ä´N¬OBear Territory¡]ºµªº»â¤g¡^¡CªG¯u§Ú¦bºµªº»â¤g¤W¡A»P¥þ®a¤@°_«×¹L¤F¥Ã¥ÍÃø§Ñ¥B»Ä²¢­W»¶¨Ö³¯ªº¾Ç¥Í®É¥ú¡C
¡@¡@¥»®Ñ±o¥H¥X¥Z¡A­nÁÂÁ¤¸·Ó¥Xª©¤½¥qªº®ï®ï´Á¬ß¡B­@¤ßµ¥­Ô¡A±q°_·N¦Ü§¹¦¨¡A³ºµMªá¤Fªñ¤T¦~ªº®É¶¡¡A¦¹¦¸­Y¤£¬O¥xÆW¤j¾Çªk«ß¾Ç¬ã¨s©Ò¸gÀÙªk²Õ¤ý©v¶¯¦P¾Çªº¨ó§U®Õ½Z¡A§Ú·Q§Ú¥i¯àÁÙ¬O¨S¦³«i®ð¥X³o¥»®Ñ¡C®Ñ¤¤¦¬¿ý¤F§Úªñ´X¦~¨Ó¡A¦b´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¦¨¥ß«e«á©Ò¼g¹Lªº£¸¨Ç¤å³¹¡A¦³¨Ç¸`¿ý¦Û§Ú©ó¥qªk°|½Õ¿ì¨Æ´Á¶¡¼¶¼g¤§¬ã¨s³ø§i¡A¦³¨Ç´¿¦b¾Ç³N·|ij¤W«ÅŪ¹L¡A¦³¨Ç«h´¿µoªí©ó¾Ç³N´Á¥Z¤W¡AÁÙ¦³´X½g§Ú¦b¬ü°ê¾Ç²ß®É¤§­^¤å½×µÛ¡A¦h¥b»P¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¶D³^¨î«×¤§ÀË°Q¦³Ãö¡A¤]¦³«Y´¼¼z°]²£¹êÅéªk«ß¾A¥Î°ÝÃD¤§±´°Q¡A¦Ó§Y¨Ï¬O¦³Ãö¹êÅéªk¤§½×­z¡A¤]¦h¥H§P¨MµûªR¬°°ò¦¡C­È¦¹´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¤´ÄÝÀ¦¥®¨à¤§»Ú¡AÂǦ¹¾÷·|¶°µ²¦¨¥U¡A¤@¤è­±§@¬°¦Û¤v¾Ç²ß´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤§¬ö©À¡A¨Ã¨£ÃÒ¥xÆW³o¤G¤Q¦h¦~¨Ó´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¤§±À¼s»Pµo®i¡F¤@¤è­±¤]§Æ±æ¯à¹ï¥xÆW´¼¼z°]²£¥qªk¤å¤Æ¤§´£¤ÉºÉºøÁ¡¤§¤O¡C¥xÆW¹L¥h´¼¼z°]²£¥qªk¤å¤Æ¤§¹¼¥F¡A¼f§P¹ê°È¤§¯Ê®u«Y¥D¦]¤§£¸¡A§Æ±æ¥»®Ñ¤§¥X¥Z¡A¯àÄ~Äò«e½ú­Ì¤w¶}±Ò¤§¸ô¡A´£¤É¾Ç³N»P¹ê°È¤§µ²¦X¡Aªk«ß»P¬ì§Þ¤§¾ã¦X¡A¤½ªk»P¨pªk¤§¿Ä¦X¡A¨Ï¥xÆW¤§´¼¼z°]²£ªk¨î¶}ªáµ²ªG¨ÃÄ~Äò½´«kµo®i¡C
¡@¡@ÅZµM¦^­º¡A§Ú¦b¥xÆW¥x¥_¦a¤èªk°|±Nªñ¤Q¤­¦~ªºªk©x¥Í²P¤¤¡A¿ì²z¹L¥Á¡B¦D¡B¤Ö¦~¡B²©ö¡B°õ¦æµ¥¨Æ¥ó¡A´Á¶¡¤]¦Ü¥qªk°|¾á¥ô¹L¥H¬ã¨s¤u§@¬°¥D¤§½Õ¿ì¨Æªk©x¡A¨Ã­u¬ü¶i­×¬ãŪºÓ¤h¡B³Õ¤h¡A³o¼Ëªº¸gÅçÅý§Úªº¤H¥ÍÂ×´I³\¦h¡AÀH«á½Õ¦Ü´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|¡A¤j¶q®×¥óªº²Ö¿n¡A§ó¥R¹ê§Ú¦b´¼¼z°]²£ªk»â°ìªº¾Ç²ß¡AÂÔ¥H¦¹®Ñ¤§¥X¥Z¡A§@¬°§Úªk©x¥Í²P¤§¬ö©À¡C¦¹¥~¡A­nÁÂÁ´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|ªº°ª¨q¯u°|ªø¡A¥H¤Î«ü¾É¦Ñ®vRobert P. Merges±Ð±Â¡A¦Ê¦£¤§¤¤¡A«D±`Àµ¤Á¦a°w¹ï³o¥»µÛ§@¼¶¤å±ÀÂË¡C³Ì«á¡A·PÁ§ڪº¤÷¥À¡AÂÔ¥H¦¹®Ñ©óª÷¨ß¦~Ämµ¹Äݨߪº¤÷¿Ë¡A¤]­n·PÁ±æ©d¦¨»ñªº¥ý¥Í¤Î¤½±C¡A§ó­n·PÁ¤T­Ó¨à¤l¡A¬°¤FÂ×´I¶ý¶ýªº¤H¥Í¡A¤G«×ÄƬv¹L®ü¡A«e¤@¤ÑÁÙ¦b¥xÆWªº¤p¾Ç°Ñ¥[¾Ç®Õ¹B°Ê·|¡A¹j¤Ñ¤w¦Ü¬ü°êªº¤p¾Ç¤W½Ò¡A§Æ±æ¥L­Ìªº¤H¥Í¤]¦]¦¹¦Ó§óÅãºë±m¡C

ºµ»w±ö
¤G¡³¤@¤@¦~¬K¤Ñ
©ó´¼¼z°]²£ªk°|

 
 ª`·N¨Æ¶µ¡G
1. ±ý¿ïÁÊ¡i«ö½g¦C¦L¡j¡A½Ð¥ýÁʶR¡i¤ë¥¹ª¾ÃÑ®wÂI¼Æ¡j§Y¥i¦Û¦æ¤U¸ü¦C¦L¡C
2. ÁʶR¡i¤ë¥¹ª¾ÃÑ®w¡jªº·|­û¡A¦b±z§¹¦¨¥I´Ú¤âÄò¤§«á¡A§Ú­Ì±N©ó¤@¦Ü¤G­Ó¤u§@¤Ñ¤º¡A¥H email ±M¨ç³qª¾±z±Ò¥ÎÂI¼Æ¡C
¡@­Y¦³«æ»Ý¨Ï¥ÎªÌ¡A½Ð¬¢«ÈªA±M½u 886-2-23756688 ¤À¾÷ 502 ¡ã 505¡A§Ú­Ì±N¥H¡uÀH¿ï¦C¦L¡v¤è¦¡´£¨Ñ¡C
3. ½u¤WÁʮѨì³f¤C¤é¤º¡A¦p¹ï®ÑÄy¤º®e¦³¥ô¦óºÃ¼{¥²¶·´«³fªÌ¡A½Ð©ó¤C¤é¤º³s¦Pµo²¼±H¦^¥»¤½¥q§ó´«¡C
4. ®ÑÄy°h´«³f³B²z§@·~®É¶¡¬ù¤Q­Ó¤u§@¤Ñ ( ¤£§t¨Ò°²¤é )¡C
5. ¥Ñ©ó³f¹B¤½¥q°e³f¨ì©²»Ý¸gñ¦¬¤âÄò¡A½Ð°È¥²¯d¤U¦³¤H¥iñ¦¬¤§¦¬¥ó¦a§}¡AÁקK³f¥óº¢¯d³f¹B ¤½¥q©µÌX¦¬¥ó¡B®É¶¡·l¥¢¡C
6. ­Y±z¿ïÁʪº®ÑÄy¥]§t¹wÁʮѡA¥»¯¸±N±Ä§å¦¸±Hµo§@·~¡A«Ý¥X®Ñ«á¤@¨Ö±Hµo¡F­Y»Ý¤À¦¸±Hµo¡A°u¦¬ 80 ¤¸ª«¬y³B²z¶O¡C
7. 2016¦~1¤ë1¤é°_¡A¤ë¥¹ª¾ÃÑ®wÂI¼Æ¡B¤ë¥¹«~µû®a¡B¤¸·Ó¹q¤l®Ñ¡B¤ë¥¹Âø»x¨t¦C¹q¤lª©¤£¾A¥Î¤C¤ÑŲ½à´ÁªA°È¡C>>¸Ô²Ó»¡©ú<<
8. ¤¸·Óºô¸ô®Ñ©±«O¯d±µ¨ü­q³æ»P§_ªºÅv§Q¡C
9. ¤¸·Óºô¸ô®Ñ©±«ÈªA±M½u¡G886-2-2375-6688 ¤À¾÷ 502 ¡ã 505¡C


¤¸·ÓŪ®ÑÀ]
¤ë¥¹«~µû®a ¿P¤j¤¸·Ó¦W®a½×¾Â
¤ë¥¹ª¾ÃÑ®w ¤ë¥¹ªk«ß¤ÀªR®w
¤¸·Óµû¶q®w ¤ë¥¹Âå¨Æªkºô
¤ë¥¹·|­p°]µ|ºô
´Á¥Z¼Æ¦ìªA°È ªÀ¸s¥­¥x ŪªÌªA°È Ãö©ó¤¸·Ó
ŪªÌªA°È±M½u¡G+886-2-23756688¡@¶Ç¯u¡G+886-2-23318496¡@«ÈªA«H½c
¦a§}¡G»O¥_¥«À]«e¸ô28 ¸¹ 7 ¼Ó¡@¤¸·Ó¥Xª©¦³­­¤½¥q¡@²Î½s¡G16604673
Copyright © ¤¸·Ó¥Xª© All rights reserved. ª©Åv©Ò¦³¡A¸T¤îÂà¶K¸`¿ý