醫師之注意義務與病患承諾的互斥關係?【月旦時論】 試閱
Mutually Exclusive Relationship between Due Diligence of Doctor and Consent of Patients?
醫師實施符合醫療準則的醫療行為不會排斥病患承諾之適用。實務見解採取互斥關係的解釋方法,不僅違反當代醫病關係強調的病人自主原則,而且造成故意、過失及犯罪評價階層的系統衝突。另外,儘管醫療行為確能提高治癒機會,惟醫師擅斷變更手術仍然不可主張假設同意,否則將會侵害病患如何決定採取符合自身利益之最適醫療的自決權。
The medical behaviors in compliance with medical standards will not exclude the application of patient consent. Jurisdiction adopt mutually exclusive interpretation methods, which not only violates the principle of patient autonomy emphasized in contemporary medical-patient relations, but also causes systematic conflicts in the evaluation class of intention, negligence and crime. In addition, although the medical behaviors improve the chance of cure, doctors arbitrarily change the operation still cannot claim hypothetical consent, otherwise it will infringe the patient’s right to self-determination in deciding to adopt the most appropriate medical treatment in their own interests.
128-144