【醫療民事法】隆乳手術注射物致乳房組織病變案:醫療糾紛在民事事件舉證責任之分配【學習式判解評析】 試閱
The Burden of Proof in the Aesthetic Medicine: On the Refinement of Burden of Proof in the Medical Legal Practices
醫療訴訟中如何分配舉證責任以平衡醫病雙方利益,向為爭議問題。本件判決明白揭示醫療上說明告知義務之履行應由醫師或醫院負舉證責任,並說明醫師違反病歷製作保存義務、醫療行為涉有重大醫療瑕疵時,舉證責任應如何分配。本文擬整理法院判決理由,並就上開三種情形所涉之民事醫療訴訟舉證責任分配之爭議進行評析。
How to distribute the burden of proof during the medical legal suits to balance the interests of two parties, is always a disputed issue. The judgement discussed in this article announced that the duty of disclose should be fulfilled by the physician or the hospital, and explained how to distribute the burden of proof when the duty of history-preserving might be violated, and when there could be major medical faults during taking a medical treatment. The reasons of the judgement are reorganized and the disputes about the distribution of the burden of proof in medical legal suits are analyzed in this article.
120-137