問對問題找答案——論醫療民事訴訟的證據提出與應對【本期企劃】 試閱
Seeking Answers through the Right Questions: “Evidence Presentation and Response in Medical Civil Litigation”
在臺灣現行的醫療鑑定制度下，法院、當事人及代理人如何擬定妥適的鑑定問題以釐清爭點，乃至法院如何審查鑑定意見是否契合案情以形成心證，對於裁判之效率及正確性皆極為關鍵。本文以醫療民事訴訟中之證據提出為切入點，依序分析法院或當事人關於「過失」或「因果關係」等待證事實應如何擬定鑑定問題，以及法院應如何針對醫療鑑定意見踐行證據調查，俾供我國實務界先進參酌。
Under the current medical appraisal system in Taiwan, how the court, the parties and their attorneys formulate appropriate appraisal questions to clarify the disputes, and how the court examines whether the appraisal opinion fits the case to form evidence is extremely important for the efficiency and correctness of the judgment. This article takes the presentation of evidence in medical civil litigation as a starting point and sequentially discusses how the court or parties should formulate appraisal questions regarding “negligence” or “causal relationship,” as well as how the court should conduct an evidentiary investigation in relation to medical appraisal opinions, providing advanced references for the practical field.
018-028
